2011: Green Bay Packers - Pittsburgh Steelers, 31-25

2010: New Orleans Saints - Indianapolis Colts, 31-17

2009: Pittsburgh Steelers - Arizona Cardinals, 27-23

2008: New York Giants - New England Patriots, 17-14

2007: Indianapolis Colts - Chicago Bears, 29-17

2006: Pittsburgh Steelers - Seattle Seahawks, 21-10

2005: New England Patriots - Philadelphia Eagles, 24-21

2004: New England Patriots - Carolina Panthers, 32-29

2003: Tampa Bay Buccaneers - Oakland Raiders, 48-21

2002: New England Patriots - Saint-Louis Rams, 20-17

2001: Baltimore Ravens - New York Giants, 34-7